Book Review: Helgoland by Carlo Rovelli

As travel was on the cards, I decided to pick up a book that’s rich with storytelling, conversational and intriguing, without being a 500-page commitment. Helgoland (170 pages) felt like the perfect choice. I had started it two weeks ago but never found the time to finish it. It was first published in 2020. There’s something about reading while traveling that makes the experience even better. It’s like hanging out with a favorite author…and the best part? They never judge you for rereading the same sentence five times. (lol)

Carlo Rovelli is a theoretical physicist known for his work on loop quantum gravity, and in Helgoland, he takes readers through the strange and fascinating world of quantum mechanics. The book isn’t just about equations and theories; it’s about the people who shaped them and the implications these ideas have on how we understand reality itself.

At times, I wonder what I’d say or discuss if I ever got the chance to meet one of my intellectual heroes. I’d probably just be awestruck, especially if I found myself sitting face-to-face with people like Dr. Brian Greene or Neil deGrasse Tyson or Richard Dawkins or Leonard Susskind. Though, let’s be real, I’d probably just nod enthusiastically while my brain desperately tries to keep up. (lol)

The Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

Coming back to Helgoland, the title of the book comes from the island of Helgoland, where Werner Heisenberg had a breakthrough in 1925 that laid the groundwork for quantum mechanics. Rovelli walks us through this moment, Heisenberg struggling with the inconsistencies of classical physics, making a radical decision to focus only on observable quantities, and ultimately arriving at matrix mechanics, a key foundation of quantum theory.

This shift was huge. Instead of trying to describe what happens to an atom between observations, Heisenberg’s approach focused only on what could be measured. It worked, but it also introduced some deeply unsettling ideas, electrons jumping between states without a clear path, particles existing in multiple states at once, and the famous Schrödinger’s cat paradox, where something can be both alive and dead until observed.

The Relational Interpretation

One of the central arguments in Helgoland is Rovelli’s take on quantum mechanics, known as the relational interpretation. Instead of treating particles as having fixed properties, he argues that properties only exist in relation to other things.

For example, if you and I look at the same clock, we might agree on the time. But if we were moving at different speeds (say, I’m in a spaceship and you’re on Earth), we’d see different times. This idea, relativity, already exists in physics. Rovelli extends it to quantum mechanics: a particle’s properties aren’t absolute but depend on its interactions with other objects. If something isn’t interacting, it might as well not exist. Basically, the universe is just one big game of “if no one texts me, do I even exist?” I added this line, just to put forward what I meant by all of this.

This interpretation moves away from the idea that observation (by a conscious human) causes the wave function to collapse. Instead, measurement is just another interaction, any exchange of information between systems. It’s a perspective that challenges our instinct to see the world as made up of things with inherent, unchanging properties. So basically, the universe doesn’t care if you’re watching, it’s doing its thing with or without our approval.

Quantum Physics Meets Ancient Wisdom

Rovelli doesn’t just stick to physics. He connects quantum mechanics to philosophy, particularly the ideas of Nagarjuna, a Buddhist philosopher who argued that nothing exists independently, it only exists in relation to something else. Turns out, ancient philosophers and quantum physicists were both onto the same thing, reality is just one big interconnected group project.

Rovelli finds parallels between these ancient ideas and modern physics, making the case that relational thinking has always been part of human thought, even if it took science a while to catch up.

He also touches on the political and intellectual climate of the time, bringing in figures like Lenin and Bogdanov. Some of these tangents might feel unexpected, but they add context to how science evolves, not in isolation but in conversation with broader cultural and philosophical movements.

Why Does Rovelli Bring This Up?

Rovelli notices a similarity between the arguments from the early 20th century and today’s conversations about quantum mechanics. Lenin believed in a solid, unchanging reality, which is like the idea that particles have set characteristics, even if we don’t look at them. In contrast, Bogdanov’s idea emphasizes that things only have meaning when they’re connected to other things, which fits with Rovelli’s belief that quantum properties only matter when they relate to other systems.

Rovelli points out that figuring out what reality really is isn’t just a question for physicists; it’s a big philosophical question that people have been trying to answer for more than a hundred years, as seen in the works of Lenin and Bogdanov.

Takeaway

One of the reasons I enjoy Rovelli’s books is that they don’t feel like textbooks. Helgoland isn’t a dry, technical breakdown of quantum mechanics. Instead, it reads like a conversation with someone who genuinely loves the subject and wants to share its wonder.

Rovelli has a way of making complex ideas feel approachable without oversimplifying them. He doesn’t pretend quantum mechanics is easy, it’s weird, counterintuitive, and often frustrating. But instead of just telling us what quantum theory says, he takes us through why it came to be, the struggles scientists faced, and the different ways people have tried to make sense of it.

Is It for You?

If you’re looking for a deep dive into the equations and technical details of quantum mechanics, Helgoland might not be enough. Rovelli’s focus is more on the conceptual side, what these ideas mean and how they challenge the way we think about reality.

For readers interested in the philosophical implications of quantum mechanics or those who enjoy a mix of science and history, this book is a great pick. It’s not about giving definitive answers (because, honestly, physics doesn’t have them yet) but about opening up new ways of thinking.

In a nut shell, Helgoland is an engaging exploration of one of the strangest areas of science, written in a way that’s both thought-provoking and accessible. Rovelli brings together physics, philosophy, and history to show why quantum mechanics isn’t just a set of abstract equations but a fundamental shift in how we understand the universe.

It’s a book that doesn’t just explain quantum mechanics it makes you see the world differently. And really, isn’t that what the best books do?

Explore further